1. Two Methods of HbA1c Testing
There are two main ways to measure Hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c).
– Point-of-Care Testing (POCT): This method uses a small, portable device in a doctor’s office or clinic to get a result from a capillary blood sample (fingertip) within minutes.
– Standard Laboratory Test: This method involves drawing venous blood from the arm, which is then sent to a central laboratory equipped with large analytical instruments for analysis. The results typically take a few hours to a day.
2. Convenience vs. Accuracy
– Advantages of Point-of-Care Testing: The biggest advantages are ‘speed’ and ‘convenience.’ Patients can find out their HbA1c level on the day of their visit and immediately discuss treatment plan adjustments with their doctor.
– The Issue of Accuracy: However, point-of-care devices may not be as precise as the large analyzers in a standard laboratory. Small errors can occur depending on the testing environment, device maintenance, and user proficiency. While many devices are certified by the National Glycohemoglobin Standardization Program (NGSP) and their reliability has greatly improved, slight differences from the standard lab method can still exist.
3. The Role of the Standard Test
Therefore, for an ‘initial diagnosis’ of diabetes or when making critical treatment decisions, the principle is to rely on the results from the most accurate and reliable standard laboratory test. Point-of-care testing is very useful for ‘monitoring’ the management status of already diagnosed patients and for providing rapid feedback.
Summary: While the immediate results from a point-of-care A1c test are very convenient, the standard test performed in a large laboratory is used as the more accurate benchmark when absolute precision is required, such as for the initial diagnosis of diabetes.
Leave a Reply